Royal Caley logo

Royal Caledonian
Horticultural Society

contact e-mail



home information charter events awards show publications people
education features pictures PlantandGrow site index history web links forum


2006 Presentation of Awards

The following awards were presented at the 197th Annual General Meeting of the Society in he Lecture Theatre of the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh’ the Scottish Horticultural Medal (SHM), the Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother Medal in Horticulture and the Dr. Patrick Neill Medal by Professor Neil Douglas, President of the Royal College of Physicians, Edinburgh and the Dr. Andrew Duncan Medal and Certificates of Merit by Sir Peter Hutchison Bt., CBE, Honorary President of the Caley.

The Scottish Horticultural Medal (SHM)

the Scottish Horticultural Medal. These awards are usually made to professional horticulturalists and on this occasion is awarded to David Spray.

David Spray receives the SHM


The Institute of Horticulture nominated David Spray, of Pentland Plants, in recognition of his foresight and leadership in promoting new nursery techniques and developing novel bedding plants. Horticulture is David’s life and hobby. Through his father who moved from Kirkcaldy Parks Department to a small nursery near Dalkeith, David had an early introduction to horticulture. He progressed to his own nursery at Loanhead in 1967 where, initially, he produced the standard nursery crops of the 60s. Increased production costs, resulting from the ‘oil crisis ‘and competition from imported Dutch chrysanths, led to diversification and saw the beginnings of the current garden centre. His passion for plants eventually brought him to concentrate on producing chrysanths and bedding plants for direct sale.

Discovering ‘plug production’ while on a holiday in Florida, he turned his attention to the development of automated plant production. The "Ready to Grow" concept proved extremely popular and the increased production enabled an extension of sales beyond the garden centre to other growers and Local Authorities. A fervent believer in promoting Scottish horticulture, his bedding plants are labelled “Scottish Grown, for your Scottish Garden”.

Passionately keen to encourage staff, those who have served the company well, and show a flair for horticulture, are offered training courses, visits to the States, and promotion. His dedication, judgement and innovative mind have proved of great benefit to Scottish horticulture. The Royal Caledonian Horticultural Society is delighted to award David Spray The Scottish Horticultural Medal.

The Queen Elizabeth, The Queen Mother Medal in Horticulture.

The Queen Elizabeth, the Queen Mother Medal was inaugurated in 1990 to commemorate the 90th birthday of the Society’s late patron: it is an Annual Award for outstanding services to Scottish Horticulture by non-professionals.

The 2005 Queen Elizabeth, The Queen Mother Medal in Horticulture is awarded to Jim Williams.

Jim Williams receives the Queen Elizabeth, the Queen Mother Medal in Horticulture

Jim Williams’ interest in gardening and horticulture took off in 1975, when he was persuaded to enter some onion ‘setts’ at his local Flower Show in Pathhead, a first small step which led to his involvement with vegetable growing and showing on a national scale. Joining the UK National Vegetable Society (NVS) in 1979, he progressed through the Management Committee and National Executive Committee to become Chairman of the Scottish Branch in 1996.

Since his appointment to the NVS Examination Board in 1995, he has been responsible for restructuring the theory and practical examinations, and has set and scheduled NVS Practical and Theory Examinations for the 5 UK Centres which handle some 30 to 40 candidates annually. He has exhibited for many years at both local and national Shows, winning many awards throughout the UK and sharing a Gold Medal award for the NVS stand at Gardening Scotland 2005. He is a much sought after Judge and each year gives talks to over 20 Horticultural Societies.

Despite full time employment as a biologist at the Moredun Institute and pressing NVS duties, Jim still finds time to support his local Society and serve on its management committee. He is also a member of The Caley and four other Lothian societies. In enthusiastically promoting vegetable production to young and old, within Scotland and throughout the UK, he is an outstanding example of leadership and commitment. The Royal Caledonian Horticultural Society is proud to present Jim Williams with the Queen Elizabeth, The Queen Mother Medal in Horticulture.

Dr Patrick Neill Medal

The Neill Prize was established in 1851 by Dr Patrick Neill, one of the Founders and the first Secretary of the Society, who left £500 to furnish, every two or three years, a medal or other reward to a distinguished Scottish botanist or cultivator. Recently, Council topped-up the fund to allow ‘annual’ awards.

The 2005 Dr Patrick Neill Award goes to  Ian McNaughton

Ian McNaughton receives the Dr Patrick Neill Medal

A doctorate from Oxford for research into the ecology and genetics of field poppies, led to Ian McNaughton’s appointment as a breeder of Brassica crops at the Scottish Crop Research Institute: the most notable example of his work there was the inter-generic hybrid Raphanobrasssica (a radish-kale hybrid), a crop plant with potential for disease resistance.

In retirement, Ian has turned his attention to the improvement of Autumn-flowering gentians through breeding and selection. Lacking initial success, he developed a strategy involving a ‘gene pool’ created from four species, focussing first on obtaining a neater, more compact growth form, especially important for pot or container culture, and secondly improving all aspects of flowering.

Ian’s commitment and perseverance over the last fifteen years has produced new gentian selections that flower earlier than those currently available, thus extending the flowering season: his new hybrids are also multi-headed, with improved flower shape and depth of colour, some with unique markings, others with an increased number of petals.

Four named cultivars are being mass multiplied and will be distributed throughout the European Union by a specialist Dutch firm. Recent interest has been shown by growers in Canada, temperate U.S.A. and New Zealand. These possible markets are currently being investigated

For his enterprise and diligence in plant breeding, The Royal Caledonian Horticultural Society is delighted to present Ian McNaughton with the Dr Patrick Neill Medal.

The Andrew Duncan Medal

Dr Andrew Duncan was a ‘Founding Father’ of the Caledonian Horticultural Society. Established in 2003 through the benevolence of the Caley’s Honorary President, Sir Peter Hutchison, and further supported by a bequest, it complements the Dr Patrick Neill Medal, which is awarded to botanists or cultivators. This medal honours distinguished service by an educationist, adviser or administrator.

The 2005 Award goes to Chrisopher Dingwall

 Christopher Dingwall receives the Andrew Duncan Medal

Christopher Dingwall, a committed and enthusiastic supporter of gardens and designed landscapes in Scotland, with unrivalled knowledge on their history, was employed as a Conservation Officer by the Garden History Society (GHS) for 12 years. His contributions during that period were beyond the call of duty and, though no longer in post, he continues generously on a voluntary basis to advise the GHS and individuals about research in Scotland.

His post with The Garden History Society involved the recording, research and conservation of Scotland’s rich garden heritage. With his passionate commitment to make that heritage more widely known, he built up a wide network of people in many fields, lectured to interested groups across Scotland, and has given generously of his time and knowledge to innumerable individuals and community groups. In pursuit of his objectives, Christopher has organised conferences, authored and co-authored books, reports, journals, newsletters and articles on countless facets of garden heritage - highlighting gardens and landscapes in Scotland under threat, and bringing many garden sites to the notice of UK and international audiences. His publication, ‘Gardens in the Wild’, an exciting piece of original research, demonstrates unique knowledge of sites, literature and pictorial sources.

Christopher’s service to horticulture in Scotland as an educationist, advisor and administrator can be truly described as ‘outstanding’ and the Royal Caledonian Horticultural Society are pleased to make him the award of The Dr Andrew Duncan Medal.

Certificates of Merit

The ‘Certificate of Merit’, introduced for the first time at the 2002 AGM, is intended to acknowledge a wide range of services or contributions to Scottish horticulture, primarily to individual societies, by an individual, amateur or professional.

The first Certificate of Merit goes to Robbie Roberts.

Robbie Roberts receives the Certificate of Merit

Robbie Roberts was born in Wales. Following army service with the Life Guards in London, he re-entered civilian life as a trade representative for a chemical company in Scotland and, in time, became the UK Sales Manager.

Since Robbie joined ‘The Caley’ in 1992, his flair for ‘sales’ has been put to good use. He served for many years on Council and established an impressive reputation as a Sales Convenor of great industry and dedication - coupled with a boundless sense of fun. He has arranged bulb-planting at the Inch, sales of bedding plants at Saughton Winter Gardens and bulbs, assorted plants, hanging baskets and containers at Spring and Summer Shows, arranged the bulk ordering of seeds for members and conjured up a never–ending supply of horticultural magazines for every occasion – from lecture evenings to coach trips.

Robbie was always first to arrive for morning duties - most notably, when stewarding at each of the Gardening Scotland Shows: his speciality there was ‘controlling’ the Stewards’ Car Park. Robbie’s outstanding contribution to ‘The Caley’, and to ‘Gardening Scotland’, has been much appreciated by his colleagues. He is very worthy recipient of this award.

Watt Russell receives the Certificate of Merit

Watt Russell receives the Certificate of Merit

Watt Russell’s consuming interest in plants, kindled at a gardening class at Hawick High School, led him initially to consider a career in horticulture. Discouraged, however, by the low rates of pay then prevailing, he opted instead for a more lucrative career in ‘precision engineering’ - retaining gardening as a life-long, rewarding and very fulfilling hobby.

With a special interest and skill in growing alpines to a high standard, he became a regular and successful exhibitor at Scottish Rock Garden Club shows. A member of ‘The Caley’ for 15 years, Watt is a stalwart within that much-appreciated, dependable band of helpers who, each year, set-up and dismantle The Caley’s Spring Show. But ‘showing’ is his passion: he served for a time as Show Secretary and, currently, he and his wife Chris hold three ‘Caley’ trophies. His interest and enthusiasm extends also to other societies, especially to the Haddington Gardening Club, with which he maintains a very active involvement.

The Royal Caledonian Horticultural Society is pleased to award Watt Russell the Certificate of Merit.


John Nicol's presentation picture to be added later


John Nicol was born into a garden-conscious Falkirk family. Following war-time service in the Royal Navy, a banking career brought him to Edinburgh where he set up home and created a fine garden in a much admired, corner site in Blackhall. He soon became a very enthusiastic member of the recently formed Blackhall Horticultural Society to which he has given more than 50 years devoted service – as Secretary for twenty years, President for three and finally as Honorary President. His support has been wide-ranging, from operating the Society’s lending library from his home, to exhibiting keenly and successfully in flower and vegetable classes and in the monthly competitions.

A founding member of the Friends of Suntrap and the Cyclamen Society, and a long-time member of the Friends of the Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh and ‘The Caley’, it is noteworthy that his first red card at a Caley Waverley Market Show was for a cyclamen exhibit. His photographic skill has provided useful illustrations for lectures and publications and for 10 years he supplied seasonal gardening advice to the quarterly Blackhall Bulletin. A cornerstone of Blackhall Horticultural Society since its early years, John’s contributions have served also the wider field of Scottish Horticulture.

The Royal Caledonian Horticultural Society is delighted to present John Nicol with The Certificate of Merit.


Note: Hugh McLauchlan died January 5th 2006, 6 days before the presentations.

Although Hugh McLauchlan first made contact with the Scottish Begonia Society at the Empire Exhibition in Glasgow in 1937, army service intervened. Hugh became a captain, was seriously wounded and decorated. After the war, with his late wife Mrs. Elizabeth McLauchlan – after whom a Begonia has been named - he went into show business, playing at venues throughout the world. Only when he became Lighting Director at Scottish Television in 1960, could he put down roots, cultivate a garden and greenhouse, and join the Scottish Begonia Society. Since then, he has been Photographic Archivist, has served for 12 years as a Vice President, then President, and he is now the Society’s Honorary President. The Society honoured him with its highest award - a Silver Medal.

His extensive travels have included visits to Botanic Gardens in Sydney and Cairns, Singapore, Bangkok, Mauritius, Zanzibar, Bombay, New Delhi, Calcutta, China, Japan and Korea. A member of the American Begonia Society for 30 years, he has attended 78 Conventions as Scottish ambassador and frequently as a speaker. He has brought back seeds and cuttings of Begonia species and cultivars for distribution in the United Kingdom. A Friend of Glasgow Botanic Garden, he has contributed extensively to the Garden’s Scottish National Begonia Collection. He is Honorary President of the Bishopbriggs Horticultural Society and a member, and successful exhibitor, at National Vegetable Society Shows (Scottish Branch).

For his many worthy contributions, The Royal Caledonian Horticultural Society is delighted to present Hugh with The Certificate of Merit.